Nutshell Sports
ULTRA-CONSERVATIVE
Football Ratings
R  a  t  i  n  g  s     i  n     S  l  o  w     M  o  t  i  o  n

[ Home ] [ Up ]
NCAA Football Superlist | NCAA Basketball Superlist
NFL Historical Ratings | NCAA Football Historical Ratings

Best College Programs in History

David Wilson's American College Football Directory of Ratings and Rankings
Kenneth Massey's Ratings Comparison
Todd Beck's Prediction Tracker

Keep It Simple

When I want serious information about the Bible, I go here:

BiblicalHeritage.org

New Resource: IFRA
for those of us who love college football
information and statistics. Spread your knowledge.

YourLinx NFL Race

Here's the NCAA solution. BCS, are you listening?

In the NFL, the teams are more evenly matched. In the NCAA, I have a plan to
solve that dilemma.

First of all, this is a system that rates the teams by how strong their
opponents are. Their current strength is determined simply by beating or
losing to other teams. What a concept.

Here is how teams are rewarded or penalized:

At the beginning of the year, the teams are aligned according to how
they finished last year. The bottom team begins with a rating of 100.
Each position going upward gets an additional 10 points.

When a stronger team wins

• The stronger team is awarded 1/5 of the opponent's rating

• The lesser team keeps the same rating

When a lesser team wins

• The stronger team loses 1/3 of the difference between their ratings

• The lesser team is awarded 1/5 of the opponent's rating

I have observed this system for many years. It seems quite adequate to me.

For the plan for NCAA, look below the following charts.

Here is how the NFL is stacking up so far this year.

This chart is meticulously maintained by Rick Turner.
You can contact Rick at the webmaster address below.

Also see the final ratings for:

Use the right arrow to see all of the chart if necessary.

What would you get if you combined these ratings of win/loss
with the margin of victory ratings of Nutshell Sports?

You'd get the NFL Special Menu Combo!

Final YourLinx Ratings for 2007 - posted 02/13/2008

For this system to work in the NCAA we have to make a few changes. The teams should be allowed to
choose an opponent they think will be strong but not too strong to beat. There would be six rounds, each
team picking up two games per round. The first game would be the team they choose, while the second
game would be the team that chooses them. In the first three rounds the teams would have to choose from
their own conference. Hey, if you don't have a conference, get one, Notre Dame.

After this, all the teams have twelve games - six conference and six non-conference to mix things up a bit.
All that's left is to bang those heads together. No more wimpy schedules. No more ignoring teams you
don't want to play. No more avoiding playing other teams in your conference if they want to play you.
No more needing to be in the right conferences to get a BCS bid. There is no problem at all. Teams that
come out of nowhere and do well would be prime targets the following year for the big boys. Thus there
is no longer a struggle to be noticed. Try to find a problem with this system.

I dare you.